They all know that it is not safe to be in town so Troutman takes them off into the woods outside of town and to his cabin. He tells them to stay there while he, Chad and Drew find out what's Cordeila and Christopher's next move is. Will asks Carter to go out walking in the woods with him. Will thanks Carter for saving his life and they kiss. The next night Troutman, Chad and Drew come to the cabin and tell them that Cordeila has her guards everwhere looking for him and it's not safe to be around here. Will calls his family and tells them that they can stay on one of the islands in the Bermuda Triangle. They take a plane to Fort Lauderdale where the vampies are about to leave to go on there 21 day trip. Carter thinks he sees somebody sitting by the pool that looks like him at the Ritz Carlton. Katherine who is friends with Patrick and Micheal ask them if they could use one of there confrence rooms and Patrick lets them and he dosen't notcie Carter.
When they all get situated in the confrence rooms Katherine and the council tells them that there ridding one of the cruise ships that goes through the Bermuda Triangle. They abored the ship the next day and Carter feels like somthing is on the ship with them. Carter see's Christopher and Christopher chases him to his friends and they get on the boats and sail away from the sip. Turns out it was just a plan to get Christopher's attention.
When they find the island the find Will's family waiting for. Will's Mom Natalie, his two gay uncles Neil and Jordan and there daughter Tess and Will's brothers and sisters Ray, Max, Cassie, Rose and Lucy. There all trying to figure out the mystery of the Bermuda Triangle. There's dark magic on the island and they discover a group of witches on the island and they all have Pyrokinesis which is the abilty to control fire.
Fire is one of the five elements for the witches. The witch leader Addly and her daughter Fiona tell Carter that he's who the Horned God and Moon Godess is looking for. They tell them that the reason they see them when they die is beacuse they chosen you and you will be protected Natalie lets them stay on the island but not on her property beacuse it has a spell around it. Carter goes to sleep that night and the Horned God and Moon Godess come to him in his dream and tell him to look through the books in the libary about the Bermuda Triangle.
The next morning Ray vists him and asks him what happend and Carter tells him the whole story from him being burnded to the stake and to Cordeila and Christopher killing the Resurgents. Ray is also Resurgent and so is the rest of his family. Crater asks him to show him the libary remebring the Horned God and Moon Godess and Ray takes him down there and Carter tells him what he's looking for and Ray pulls it out for him and the book tells Carter everything you need to know about The Bermuda Triangle.
Ray tells Carter that he thinks the Bermuda Triangle has the secrect to everything. Carter tells him that he wants to go out to the center of the trangle. Ray tells him that everytime you bring back someone back to life you have a special bond a romantic bond. That means Carter has a bond with Will, Breannon and the council. Carter asks the council is he has a sepcial bond with them and they say no beacuse there the council but you do have sepcial bonds with the other people you brought back to life.
Carter goes up to Breannon and asks him if he has specila feelings for him. Breannon shakes his head but then he says that the first day at the academy that he kind of liked him and Carter still dosen't understand why Breannon was so mean to him and Breannon says he honestly dosen't know and that he's starting to have feelings for him and they are true and not what the bond is doing.
Carter asks Will the same thing and Will tells him that he always liked Carter and that the bond isn't working. Carter thinks Natalie knows but Natalie, Neil and Jordan tell him that sometimes the bond dosen't work and it only works every once in a while if its a Resurgent and Tess says that Addly and Fiona could probably stop it. Carter goes into the woods with Tess, Neil and Jordan. Carter asks them how they came to this island and how Will ended up in Kentucky.
They tell them that Katherine told them to hide out somwwhere safe because Cordeila was going to kill the Resurgents and Will went in to spy on her. They find Addly and Fiona and Carter tells them his troubles and they draw the circle and have Carter hold the sprit candle, Natalie to hold the Earth candle, Tess the Wind Candle, Neil the Fire candle and Jordan the water candle and the call on the Moon Godess and they have them take Carter's bond away and the Moon Godess appers and tells them that the bond dosen't work on him and that Will and Breannon have real feelings for him.
Carter tells Breannon that he could never love him the way that Breannon treated him and storms off and he finds Will on the beach. He tells Will that he dosen't know what to do about him and rather he wants Blake or him. Will says it's your choice and that he will be happy no matter what choice he makes. They kiss and moments later Blake comes down and asks what there doing. Carter tells him taht he was wallking around and found Will.
The next day Carter goes out to the beach and finds Chad. Carter sits by Chad and tells him that he's gla dto see him and they talk. At one time the two look into eachother's eyes until Hanna and Loren come down and ask them what there doing and they say nothing and they get into the water. Later they tell him that Chad likes him and that he should get with him instead of Blake. Cassie, Ray, Max, Rose and Lucy tell Carter to bring his friends to the rithual tonight and they tell him that they know about his specal bond and tease him about it. Ray tells them to stop and they go off into the jungle.
Ray pecks him on the lips and runs away. Carter finds Mary, Kalysta, Hanna, Loren, Christina, Katie and Ashley and tells him that he dosen't know what to do with all the boys chasing him around. He's got Blake, Will, Breannon, Chad and Ray and they tell him to go with his heart. Hanna and Loren are for Chad and the rest are for Blake beacuse he's the first one that Carter went out with. Carter says he'll deal with it once this damn rithual is over.
They go to the rithual and Addly and Fiona plan on summoning the Horned God and Moon Godess to see what there plans are with Carter. They summon them and they tell them that Cordeila suppects that there out here but dosen't know for sure. They want Carter to be the leader of all Resurgents leading them thrugh generation through generation and power and wealth and through war. Carter tells him that he's just a teenager and can't do all that but Horned God and Moon Godess believes that he can.
The next day Carter notcies that Chad starts having his problems again and admits to Carter that he was the one that was watching him but Cordeila possossed him to do it and Carter believes him. Chad is still mad leaves the island on one of the speed boat and Carter gets in with him with his powers by dreamleaping on there.
Chad tells him to get off and Carter refuses too. Chad tries to throw Carter off the boat not paying attention and they crash into a giant rock in the middle of the ocean. Chad flys on top of the rock with Carter. Carter heals himself real quick and crawls to Chad. Chad tells Carter to let him just die. Carter says he will and but he's healing hin by touching him and tells him all the nice things about him and Chad tells him to heal him and carter says that I am. Chad kisses him and Carter realises that this whole time he liked Chad but just didn't know it and they have sex.
Meanwhile Blake and Will notcie that Carter and Chad are gone and go into the jungle with Hanna, Kalysta, Marry, Ashley, Katie and Christina. They ask the witches and Fiona tells them that there together on a rock in the ocean. Chad has the power to call out to somebody and he calls out to Troutman and tells him where he and Carter are at. Carter tells Blake that he knows exactly where there at and they get in a boat but they run into a serpent.
The serpent swims around there boat but Hanna calls fire to suround there boat and the serpent eventully leaves and they make it to the rock. They get on the boat Carter and Blake kiss and he notcies Will and Chad looking at him and is unsure what to do about them. Carter passes out and the Horned God and Moon Godess come to Carter and tell him it's time to met him now. Carter wakes up and its starts to rain hard and it start hailing.
The clouds turn dark and it starts lightinging and the water turns into a huge sinking hole and they see ghostly planes up above and Carter sees Addly standing on the rock with her hands in the air controlling the power. The boat sinks into the sinking hole and they all crawl out of the water and there in a cave. Carter tells them that Addly was doing all that and Troutman tells them that he always thought there was something fishy about her. They walk through the cave without anything else to do.
Will tells them that they need to get back to the island. Carter tells them how when they have no clue how to get out of here. They walk until they reach a huge red door they open it and find the Horned God and Moon Godess. They see Christopher with them and try to run out but the Horned God shuts the door with his powers. Christopher tells Carter that his evil twin brother has taken over his place and that he never did all those things to him.
- Christian Hall as Carter (13 episodes)
- Josh Hutcherson as Blake
- Jean Luc Bilodeau as Will
- Alex Pettyfer as Ray
- Zack Roerig as Chad
- Alexander Ludwig as Troutman
- Emma Robberts as Hanna
- Dave Franco as Seth
- Debroah Ann Woll as Katherine
- Connie Brittion as Natalie
- Dylan McDermoitt as Neil
- Zachary Quinto as Jordan
- Brit Morgan as Tess
- Teddy Sears as Max
- Taissa Farmgia as Cassie
- Alexandra Breckenridge as Rose
- Lucy Hale as Lucy
- Magenia Tovah as Addly
- Jamie Brewer as Fiona