Lauren Malloy Comes Back to New York takes place after Scream: Frank Nightingale's Stalker. Hayley, Brooke and Lloyd went on vacation in New York. Hayley found out Lauren return to New York. Hayley need Leon Brooks's help who save her by Lauren when Hayley try robbed a bank, to stop Lauren to kill the people. Leon and Hayley found out a rapist who rape a housewife, 12 year old girl and 18 year old girl who is ghostface and is help Lauren but is the rapist.
- Georgie Henley as Hayley McDonald/Lauren Malloy
- Mark Wahlberg as Detective Leon Brooks
- Natasha Henstridge as Chloe Brooks
- J.C Brandy as Brooke McDonald
- Chance Crawford as Lloyd McDonald
- Bradley Cooper as Ryan Webster/The rapist and Lauren's boyfriend
- Isabella Acres as Rosie Brooks/Leon and Chloe's daughter and Katie's sister
- Caitlin Carmichael as Katie Brooks/Leon and Chloe's daughter and Rosie's sister
- Alexa Vega as Holly Harris
- Tessa Allen as Leanne Morris
- Julie Benz as Lucy Allen/A housewife
- Maisie Smith as Young Hayley McDonald/Hannah McDonald
Films Mentioned in the movie
- Carrie-mentioned by Hayley when Hayley was kidnapped by Lauren and put in the bag with lots of blood get from hospital. Hayley think she is Carrie White when she lots of blood on her body.
- Sorority Row-was watched by Natasha and Holly before Ryan raped them.
- Final Destination 3-was watched by Hayley and Brooke
- Halloween (1978)-Watched by Hannah (Lauren) and Hayley, When Hayley tell Leon about Lauren when learn about killing. The hooligans wanted Hannah (Lauren) choose they DVD. Hannah (Lauren) choose Halloween (1978). The hooligans tie Hayley in the chair. The hooligans leave Hannah (Lauren) and Hayley alone to watch Halloween (1978). The hooligans go to rape they babysitter again.