The Bag

The Bag is the third episode of Island of Murders. It premiered August 18, 2013.

Plot
It starts off with Bill (Ryan Merriman), Russell (Freddie Stroma), Justin (Chris Zylka), Derek (Shawn Ashmore) and Greg (Penn Badgley) fishing on the boat. Justin asks Bill why he wants to get married when he can just go out and have any woman and Bill says he would never do that to Karen (Maggie Grace). Greg sees a bag on a boat and Bill notices it's Ben's (Sam Trammell). Bill goes onto the boat and grabs the bag and opens it to find $1,000,000 and a gun. Russell suggest they put it back but Greg and Justin think they should take it. Derek grabs the bag and is about to put it back but Greg shoots the gun in the air and says they're taking it.

Heather (Jessica Stroup) is jogging in the woods with Karen, Wendy (Sophia Bush), Sierra (Jessica Lowndes), Carrie (Laura Ramsey), Jenna (Blake Lively) and Grace (Jaime King). Heather notices someone in the woods and tells them to show there self it is revealed to be Daniel (Alex Pettyfer). Karen says that she told him to leave Heather pushes him and tells him to go. Daniel pulls out a gun telling them to give them Karen and he'll go. Johnny (Chad Michael Murray) and Brad (Nicholas D'Agosto) attack Daniel and fight with him. The girls tell them to stop and they do. Johnny tells Daniel to leave the island and never come back and he leaves.

The girls then leave back to the hotel leaving the two guys by themselves. The next day Wendy bumps into Brad and they both apologize. Wendy thanks Brad for saving them and Brad asks her out on a date and she accepts then leaves. Wendy sees the guys and asks why they're carrying another bag and they hesitate to answer but Bill says that it's Ben's bag so he wanted to call him to come get it and she leaves. Bill says that one of them has to keep the bag and Greg volunteers. Bill says that it has to be buried but Greg refuses to bury it but Bill says that it's not theirs and Greg says that he'll do it and they leave.

Heather, Karen, Sierra, Wendy and Carrie are in Karen's room. They ask Karen why Daniel is on the island Karen says that he wants to be with Karen. Heather says that how did he know the wedding was on the island. Karen says that she accidentally emailed him since she was emailing everyone and forgot to delete his address. Heather says if he comes back she is going to call Sheriff Sanders (Josh Holloway) to arrest him.

Heather then walks to Robin's (Elizabeth Mitchell) house to get Maggie (Mackenzie Foy) she hears somebody in the woods. Greg hears someone walking and runs dropping the gun. Heather picks up the gun thinking it's Hank's and sees someone thinking it's Hank (Robert Englund) and shoots him in the chest. The person falls down dead revealing it's Greg and she starts crying and runs to her mother's house. Heather gets her mother and Maggie they run outside. Heather says that she shot Greg by accident but find Greg's body not there. Heather says that she just shot him and didn't mean to shoot him. Heather sees Hank carrying Greg's body and the bag and walks away.